By Thapelo Molefe
The University of Johannesburg (UJ) has secured a court order preventing former senior administrator Mzwakhe Matukane from accessing his pension benefits while the institution pursues a civil claim against him over alleged involvement in a fraudulent student accommodation payment scheme.
The Johannesburg High Court ordered the University of Johannesburg Pension Fund to withhold the former employee’s pension benefits pending the finalisation of civil proceedings instituted by the university in the Labour Court.
The court application followed a decision by the UJ Pension Fund board on 15 September to release Matukane’s pension benefits. In correspondence to his legal representatives dated 23 September, the fund confirmed that it had resolved to release the benefits, subject to the submission of the required documents.
The fund had questioned whether UJ had sufficiently established the legal grounds for withholding the pension under section 37D of the Pension Funds Act.
While it acknowledged that some of the university’s allegations could support a damages claim based on negligence or gross negligence, it said these did not necessarily establish theft, fraud or dishonest misconduct. UJ subsequently approached the High Court to prevent the payout while its civil claim remained pending.
In a judgment handed down on 5 November, Judge Nelisa Mali found that UJ had established a prima facie case of dishonesty against the former employee, based on allegations that he authorised payments to a private accommodation provider despite students denying that they had lived at the premises.
The university is seeking damages arising from the alleged misconduct, which it says caused it substantial financial losses.
According to the judgment, UJ’s investigations uncovered irregularities involving accommodation payments claimed for students who had allegedly been allocated to different accommodation providers or had never occupied the properties for which payments were made.
Of particular concern was an incident in August 2023, when the former employee was allegedly informed that two students had expressly denied being accommodated by a service provider. Despite this, he allegedly instructed that outstanding payments should proceed.
The university further alleged that about R400,096 was paid to the service provider in two instalments during July and August 2023, with a substantial portion subsequently transferred to a representative associated with another accommodation provider.
The court also considered findings from a lifestyle audit, which identified several bank accounts linked to the former employee, his spouse and associated entities, as well as deposits and financial transactions that investigators said could not readily be reconciled with his declared sources of income.
The transactions in question amounted to approximately R821,112.28.
However, the former employee disputed the allegations, maintaining that the payments had been processed in accordance with established procedures and that the university had failed to demonstrate that he acted dishonestly.
He also claimed that he had blown the whistle on the disputed transaction and disputed the significance of a payment of approximately R97,000 reflected in his bank account, saying it originated from Old Mutual and was unrelated to the accommodation scheme.
Mali said the allegations needed to be considered collectively, particularly the alleged authorisation of payments despite students denying that they had occupied the accommodation.
“The alleged authorisation of payments notwithstanding the express denials by students, the apparent irregularities in the supporting documentation and the inconsistencies in the explanations concerning the financial transactions, considered cumulatively, establish a prima facie case of dishonesty,” the judge said.
The judge, however, emphasised that the matter had not reached a final determination and that the former employee’s explanations could still be accepted when the main case was heard.
“I do not consider it necessary, at this stage, to make a definitive finding that the third respondent (Mzwakhe Matukane) committed fraud or dishonesty. That would amount to determining issues reserved for the Labour Court proceedings,” Mali said.
The court found that the university had demonstrated a sufficient basis to preserve the pension benefits while its civil claim remained pending, particularly because the amount it was seeking to recover was substantially higher than the former employee’s pension benefits.
The ruling follows a separate Labour Court judgment involving another former UJ senior official, Andries Helani, who was ordered to repay more than R18-million to the university after being found to have accepted bribes from private student accommodation providers.
Helani, who was the university’s former senior director of student affairs, received more than R3.2-million through 366 payments from accommodation providers and related parties between March 2021 and March 2024.
The payments were made while he was responsible for overseeing the accreditation of privately owned student residences funded through the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS).
The Labour Court found that Helani had failed to declare his relationships with the accommodation providers and had helped secure accreditation for two properties in Braamfontein that were supposed to accommodate 1,441 students but had only 299 beds.
Investigators who conducted a physical inspection found that only one UJ student was living in each of the two buildings, despite the properties having been approved for a combined 1,441 beds. They also found that Mahlatse Investments, which had applied for accreditation, did not own or manage the properties.
The university paid just over R17-million to the entities linked to the properties, while its payment merchant, Fundi Capital, claimed more than R1-million in fees.
Judge Reynaud Daniels found that the payments Helani received were bribes for his role in securing the accreditation of the properties and described him as an active participant in a scheme to defraud the university.
In the latest matter, Judge Mali ordered the pension fund to withhold Matukane’s benefits until the civil claim under case number 2026-131705 has been finalised.
Matukane was also ordered to pay the costs of the High Court application on an attorney-and-client scale.
INSIDE EDUCATION











